The Plymouth Cycling Campaign (PCyC) meetings are open to all
- Anyone who would like to get involved in our campaigns to improve cycling in Plymouth and to help raise the profile of sustainable transport is very welcome to attend these meetings. We need all the help we can get!
- Or just come along to find out what we’re up to – you’ll be very welcome whatever type of cyclist you are, or even if you don’t cycle but would like to! And any comments you may have will be welcome too.
Scroll down for minutes of last committee meeting followed by minutes of last open meeting
Date of next open meeting on Zoom: Thursday 3rd June 2021; 6 – 7.30 pm
THE AGENDA IS PUBLISHED HERE A WEEK OR SO IN ADVANCE OF THE NEXT MEETING
The link to the next Zoom meeting will be sent out a few days before the meeting to those subscribed to our email list. If you are not yet subscribed please sign up to our email list now (it’s free) to ensure you are sent the link.
The link will be live from 5.45pm so participants can check their Zoom settings or seek advice if they are not familiar with Zoom.
If you’d like to become a paid member of Plymouth Cycling Campaign with full voting rights, please visit our Join Us page for further information. The cost is £5 (annually by Standing Order).
There’s never been a better time to campaign for cycling in Plymouth!
MINUTES OF LAST COMMITTEE MEETING MEETING APRIL 8TH 2021
Present – John Abraham, Hilary Neve, Stuart Mee, Sue Jennings, Graham Wilson, Jon Stevens, Bernhard Haas, Mike Kelly
- Welcome and Apologies – Dave Gibbs, Caitlyn Hellier, Bill Nicholson
- Minutes of previous meeting 18th Feb 2021 / matters arising
- MK has not yet contacted local party leaders over council election manifestoes but is instead reviewing published manifesto commitments to put together a summary to inform members
- JA contacted Iain Stewart re feasibility study on the A386 route. Still not in a position to share anything. JA is considering contacting Cllr.Ric Cheadle
- Billacombe Rd – see below
- JA will inform Rosie Starr on future schemes we’d like to see considered under the ATF
- Meeting with Gary Streeter – see below
- Clearbrook cycling hub and café planning application – JA reviewed the comments on the planning application and was in two minds about the merits of the proposal so did not respond from PCyC leaving it to members to respond as they saw fit
- Embankment Rd to city centre – JA wrote to Rosie Starr and suggested an alternative route and requested that it be included on the agenda at the next SLG meeting on May 25th
- Reports on meetings & consultations
a) PCyC response to Major Roads Network (MRN) proposal – SM submitted comments and an acknowledgement was received
B) PCyC response Mobility Hubs – Journey Hubs proposal -JA felt that this is a good idea in principle but is unsure how it will work with hiring out e-bikes and sending people off into the traffic with no training and without safe routes to ride. HN said route recommendations would be needed and that it would make sense to have hubs where good routes exist.
c) Mobility Hubs Workshop Findings : Plymouth Uni student potential use of e-bike mobility hubs 8th March 2021 -attended by JA – lots of questions arose eg how far can the bikes be taken? Further discussion centred on the practical issues and how successful this would be in the longer term, how many would benefit and whether the funding for the bike element of the hubs could be better spent on improving infrastructure.
d) Sustrans Network Development Plan Consultation: Devon 31st March – attended by GW, BH and JA. Sustrans have reviewed routes and we are now invited to revisit their suggestions and offer comments on known issues and suggest improvements. BH is organising 4 rides to review the different sections of NCN route2 in our area and would welcome non-Sustrans members to join in subject to workable numbers of people involved. GW reported that some sections in his area had been reclassified or re-routed and he was waiting for further guidance on next steps. He flagged the report on route 2 from Endeavour Cycling Club as being helpful to the process.
BH said this review would be an opportunity to raise the routing of NCN 2 along Exeter Street; SM raised the state of NCN2 along the Embankment and discussion followed about the risk of this route being removed. SJ emphasised that we need to make the case for the importance of these routes which are heavily used by commuters as well as being a leisure route.
- Major Infrastructure Issues
a) Saltram Meadows to Colesdown Hill -proposed steps – PCyC has not yet responded to the planning application. JS, GW, BH carried out a site survey. There is a big difference in elevation between the railway track and the road at Colesdown Hill hence the need for some kind of ramp to get from track to road. Proposal is for steps with a wheeling ramp. This has caused a lot of comment on Facebook. PCC claim that a complete scheme had to be submitted to ensure funding. PCyC needs to decide whether to support or object. Discussion followed.
GW suggested that the bridge appears structurally sound and that the material under the bridge could be removed to allow the path to continue and then, with landowner consent, it could continue through the edge of the cement works to pick up the cycle lane on Billacombe Rd. It would be necessary to find out what contact has been made with the landowner and what options have been considered. SM suggested objecting unless we can see definite plans for near-future improvements that set out the timeframe and next steps. MK questioned whether we had to object or support or if a comment could be made setting out what we agreed with and what was unsatisfactory. JS questioned what people would do once they reached Colesdown Hill – it’s steep so would people bother using the path or just stick to the A379. GW suggested informing Gary Streeter, the MP for this area, of the situation and ask for his help, since he has been very supportive previously. Consultation closes on April 20th. ACTION – JS to draft a response from PCyC and then GW will forward the draft response to Gary Streeter seeking his intervention
- b) Forder Valley cycle path – PCC response to JA queries. JA raised the issue of improvements to the cycle route along Forder Valley from Leigham roundabout to the petrol station. Extensive work is planned at either end but not along this section. There is likely to be an increase in vehicle and cycle traffic along this route. Rosie Starr forwarded comments to the project manager. SJ has previously raised this with Jim Woffenden through the Cycle Delivery Group meetings but had been told there was no money available for this section. ACTION SJ to raise the issue again at the next CDG meeting
- c) Plympton to Ivybridge route – on April 30th Gary Streeter will be joining reps from PCyC and PL21 to look at 4 hotspots on this route as he wants to see them personally. Those spots are the Cot Hill crossing and crossing Ridgeway from Market Road in Plympton, the Lee Mill junction and the main junction going into Ivybridge
- PCyC presence at Tour of Britain St.2 Start, 6th Sept – JA contacted the team behind the Tour of Britain and received a favourable reply. Need to work on the assumption that the Tour will go ahead and that we will be able to be involved. Suggested a marquee / tent with info and opportunity to engage with local cyclists. Suggest working with Sustrans and Endeavour. BH has been in contact with Adam Jukes at Sustrans who is checking on logistics. BH, JS, HN all happy to help with planning.
- Bike Week – suggest that we promote this on Facebook, Twitter. Unclear at the moment whether planned group rides will be possible. Suggested using Instagram as a forum for people to post their own photos of their Bike Week rides and make this a competition and offer prizes as an encouragement
- Hooe Lake Bridge – JS has met with the group pushing this twice. They are still active and gathering a wide range of interested parties and people with different skills and pushing the bridge at every opportunity. There is a will, but practical issues remain. They are willing to knock on doors and canvass support but would welcome any support PCyC can give.
- Dates of next meetings
- Strategic Liaison Group (SLG) – 25th May
- Committee – 27th May
- Open meeting – 3rd June – this is in Bike Week so suggested an open air open meeting with people cycling to Central Park to meet up and share experience of cycling particularly if people have recently started using their bikes. Will need to be advertised on Facebook, Twitter, email.
- Additional Issues for SLG – find out what the masterplan is for the route to Sherford; concerns over Forder Valley
Minutes of the open meeting 4th March 2021
Present: John Abraham (chair), Hilary Neve, Patrick James, Sue Jennings, Cllr Andrea Johnson, John Green (PCC), Stuart Mee, Hayley Smith, Graham Wilson, Bernhard Haas, Clare Smith, Jon Stevens, Tom Unwin, Cllr Ashley West, Dean Bowles, Kit Harbottle, Ricky Lowes, Darren Foley, Mike Kelly, Marc ?, David ?, Delphine ?
- Welcome – JA
- Apologies – Bill Nicholson, Dave Gibbs
- Minutes of last open meeting
- Matters arising from minutes – none
- John Green, Low Carbon City Officer, Plymouth City Council
‘Multi-modal mobility hubs’ – JG outlined the plans for multi-modal hubs which will offer 400 ebikes for hire, electric vehicle (EV) charging points and electric vehicle car club. The timescale for the project is between now and 2023. The project is currently at the concept design stage and consultation and engagement with various stakeholders is underway at present. Hubs will vary in size from: small scale 6 metre size hub equivalent to one on-street car parking space and consisting of EV charge points at each end, ebike charging and parking and an info kiosk with journey info; double size 12m hub equivalent to a bus stop; medium size hub will also include car club vehicle parking space and a covered structure likely to include solar panel structure; larger size hubs also planned.
Work to date has focused on analysis of where best to locate these hubs (between 30-50 of them). Over 100 locations have been assessed with the aim of creating a network of sites that link in with public transport and help to achieve a switch away from private car transport.
Hubs will include live info on buses etc to help with journey planning and JG would like to include info on carbon cost of different journey modes to make it easy to switch between modes while creating a system that allows for upgrades and further integration over time. They are exploring possibilities for through ticketing using multiple modes of transport and providers. There has been a lot of interest from various groups and organisations.
Multiple project aims – improving air quality and active travel, reducing congestion and CO2 emissions while also increasing transport options for low income neighbourhoods and linking into wider wellbeing by integrating sites with wellbeing hubs. The team are investigating options for social prescribing and the provision of e-trikes / e-tandems to support those with disabilities
- Questions on above
Will there be provision for cargo bikes? This wasn’t specified in the bid but is being explored at engagement events
- Number of disability bikes? Investigating whether it’s possible to integrate this provision with planned set-up or whether separate procurement of a bespoke provision for charging will be needed. Ideally all types of bikes would fit with the same charging infrastructure but if it’s not it will be necessary to identify which sites are most suited to disability bikes and considering options over how booking would work.
- What staffing will be required to administer the booking system, maintenance, security etc? This would require a team of people and it would be from a contracted provider so it will be determined by what the market can offer. Looking into how return of bikes would work and considering different hire costs according to where bikes are collected / returned to – e.g. possibility of having geo-fenced return locations away from the hubs and people may be charged less / credited for collecting bikes from these locations to bring them back to a hub.
- Will the scheme be self-financing? The capital funding for setting up is secured but the operational costs will need to be minimised to ensure financial sustainability. Looking at options and what the market will provide.
- Can private e-bikes use the charging points? Keen to hear feedback on what the public and the market would like to see. A consultation has been launched and JG would like to hear PCyC’s view.
- Is Devon County Council aware of what’s being developed as mini-hubs look like they could fit into Devon villages for example? Yes, JG has been speaking with DCC and they have been working on EV charging.
- Through ticketing with bike hire and public transport providers – who have you spoken to? Exploring it with providers and companies. GW highlighted a particular company working in the West Midlands.
- Is there a possibility of folding e-bikes being part of the hire scheme which would help with integration with public transport? Expect to be buying standard, non-folding ebikes but this will depend on feedback and what the market offers.
- Could you also have Bromptons for hire? The funding was gained for the provision of ebikes. JG noted that they are also having to consider helmet wearing as details are worked up.
6. Brief updates on key campaigns, current infrastructure construction and PCyC meetings / communications with PCC and other bodies.
JA gave an update on works under way / beginning imminently at Forder Valley, Billacombe Rd (slow progress noted on a short section of new cycle path), Stoke Damerel to Alma Rd (good progress reported here)
Consultations currently open – Dockyard to city centre route; Plymouth major roads network; mobility journey hubs. PCyC will provide a response.
Roborough Down cycle route feasibility study has been completed by Sustrans on behalf of local authorities. At the moment nothing has been released publicly but when it is PCyC will be kept informed.
7. Strategic Liaison Group – PCyC reps and senior officers with transport responsibilities at PCC are meeting every three months to discuss and raise issues. The third meeting took place in Feb. MK reported that a positive working relationship is developing and that good intent is evident in achieving improvements in cycling and active travel and carbon reduction. Funding for projects is the key impediment. PCC does have plans made (but not shared publicly) for addressing the key schemes that are on PCyC members’ priority list. These are matched to various levels of funding that may be available in future. SM expressed concern that communication with people at PCC between three monthly meetings appears to be more difficult and reiterated that PCyC needs to keep pushing. HN pointed out that PCyC is useful to PCC and that we have been assured access to project managers on transport related schemes.
8. Endeavour Cycling Club. After the presentation at our last meeting work has continued on tackling barriers on cycle routes which are a particular concern for cyclists with adapted bikes. Considering an outdoor meeting when restrictions allow to show solidarity with members of Endeavour CC. Endeavour CC members have also been in touch with PL21 Group regarding barriers on the NCN 2 route from Ivybridge to Plymouth. A comprehensive report has been produced to highlight issues and this has been shared with Sir Gary Streeter, Sustrans and PCyC. Dialogue is already underway with GS. TU highlighted the issue with ‘cyclists dismount’ signs for disabled riders. While this hadn’t been highlighted in the report it was recognised as a key issue. In addition, the presence of double gates on NCN 27 around Clearbrook and Yelverton was also raised. Buckland Monachorum councillor Ashley West said she would follow up the gates issue. Endeavour cycling club are making Sustrans aware of the problems for those using ability cycles. JA suggested that PCyC did not need to add additional comments at this stage. SJ reported previous discussions with Peter Guy from DCC who had been looking into replacing gates with cattle grids a couple years ago. Suggestion that Sustrans need to be contacted too to find out their position.
9. Jason Luff is the new Cycling Development Officer for Plymouth and he is the man to contact if anyone is interested in setting up new cycling clubsOpen discussion on topics raised by members – no items raised
10. AOB – CS flagged reports showing real evidence of a link between obesity and covid mortality. Arguments for cycling and active travel are clearer than ever and it just shows again that we have to get people out of their cars
11. Date of next open meeting Thursday June 3rd 6pm-7.30pm